Author Topic: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)  (Read 300 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Tony O'Stark

  • Movie/Mini-Series President
  • MZPtv Administrator
  • *
  • Posts: 23731
  • Gender: Male
  • Kicks ass. Takes names. Eats chicken.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Eternity, The Company
[REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« on: January 18, 2012, 08:53:53 PM »


by A. J. Black

Awakening on a world unfamiliar, with no concept of how he arrived, Bow is targeted by sinister aliens as he seeks the truth about what happened to him. Meanwhile, the Premonition and her crew discover their disturbing fate...

Guest Starring

Lola Glaudini | Ed Westwick | Rick Worthy | Maury Sterling



Gavin Rossdale | Julian Richings | Tom Noonan | Angus MacFayden



and Peter Capaldi



Special Guest Star

Terry O'Quinn


(Airdate: January 18th, 2012)
« Last Edit: January 22, 2012, 09:12:16 PM by Tony O'Black »

CREATOR/SHOWRUNNER:

The Beacon / Kings Cross

PRODUCER:

Walker

BLACK HOLE PRODUCTIONS / THE BLACK HOLE


Offline Tony O'Stark

  • Movie/Mini-Series President
  • MZPtv Administrator
  • *
  • Posts: 23731
  • Gender: Male
  • Kicks ass. Takes names. Eats chicken.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Eternity, The Company
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #1 on: January 18, 2012, 08:55:56 PM »
And Premonition returns with part one of a two-part premiere!

Do enjoy and please leave any thoughts in this here thread.

CREATOR/SHOWRUNNER:

The Beacon / Kings Cross

PRODUCER:

Walker

BLACK HOLE PRODUCTIONS / THE BLACK HOLE


Offline Kyle West

  • MZPtv Community Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1193
  • Gender: Male
    • Kyle West @ Flickr
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #2 on: January 18, 2012, 09:01:29 PM »
Holy crap, two Trek shows have released material here in the same week!

Offline Tony O'Stark

  • Movie/Mini-Series President
  • MZPtv Administrator
  • *
  • Posts: 23731
  • Gender: Male
  • Kicks ass. Takes names. Eats chicken.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Eternity, The Company
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #3 on: January 18, 2012, 09:10:59 PM »
Today my dream of an MZP TrekVerse doesn't seem so far away...  a-1

CREATOR/SHOWRUNNER:

The Beacon / Kings Cross

PRODUCER:

Walker

BLACK HOLE PRODUCTIONS / THE BLACK HOLE


Offline Kyle West

  • MZPtv Community Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1193
  • Gender: Male
    • Kyle West @ Flickr
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #4 on: January 18, 2012, 09:50:49 PM »
If only we could get Avalon back on the air...

Anyhoo, enjoy the episode folks!

Offline Monster Zero

  • Bald Asshole
  • King of Monsters
  • *
  • Posts: 29384
  • Gender: Male
  • an easy mark for evil redheads
    • MZPtv
  • Favourite Virtual Series: The Company, Walker, Malleus Maleficarum
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #5 on: January 20, 2012, 10:46:54 AM »
Great return for STP. I know I was quite hard on the show during S1 but I've had a revelation about this recently - Tony's shows always favour enthusiasm and spectacle over cold, hard logic. They're full of homage, riffs ('scum and villainry...'), influences and nods - but that's just part of their style. There are recurring elements across everything he does (the old 'mysterious cave with pillars of light' being the best), and also a dash of cheese (here in characters like Morgan, with dialogue straight out of an 80s action flick).

Thing is, in the past I penalised the show for things like this - but I'm starting to see now that I missed the point with a lot of it. This is meant to be fun. Time-hopping is going to leave you in a big, manic mess lurching from one disaster to another, but that's kind of the point as well. So with that in mind...

Yeah, I really enjoyed this. Great pacing and momentum, an easy slot straight back into things, plenty of new plots and intrigue alongside (thankfully) some very clear answers about the previous season's secret mission statement. We've got our bad guys - a warped version of the Federation - some firmer direction with the Samuel arc, things for all the regulars to do (yes, even being a prisoner count), and a sweet ending to set up Part Two. Bravo!

Currently Writing:
SOON

Offline Tony O'Stark

  • Movie/Mini-Series President
  • MZPtv Administrator
  • *
  • Posts: 23731
  • Gender: Male
  • Kicks ass. Takes names. Eats chicken.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Eternity, The Company
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #6 on: January 22, 2012, 09:16:02 PM »
Cheers for the swift review, Lee!

Great return for STP. I know I was quite hard on the show during S1 but I've had a revelation about this recently - Tony's shows always favour enthusiasm and spectacle over cold, hard logic. They're full of homage, riffs ('scum and villainry...'), influences and nods - but that's just part of their style. There are recurring elements across everything he does (the old 'mysterious cave with pillars of light' being the best), and also a dash of cheese (here in characters like Morgan, with dialogue straight out of an 80s action flick).

Thing is, in the past I penalised the show for things like this - but I'm starting to see now that I missed the point with a lot of it. This is meant to be fun. Time-hopping is going to leave you in a big, manic mess lurching from one disaster to another, but that's kind of the point as well. So with that in mind...


Spot on. I'm entertained by shows that eschew logic in favour of escapism, and so I write the same kind of thing. I guess if you're of a similar mind, you'll enjoy what I do.

Quote
Yeah, I really enjoyed this. Great pacing and momentum, an easy slot straight back into things, plenty of new plots and intrigue alongside (thankfully) some very clear answers about the previous season's secret mission statement. We've got our bad guys - a warped version of the Federation - some firmer direction with the Samuel arc, things for all the regulars to do (yes, even being a prisoner count), and a sweet ending to set up Part Two. Bravo!




Nice one! Very happy with that. Given it throws a lot at the reader, I think, that's a generous score - but I am pleased with how it came out.  thup

CREATOR/SHOWRUNNER:

The Beacon / Kings Cross

PRODUCER:

Walker

BLACK HOLE PRODUCTIONS / THE BLACK HOLE


Offline aaron2310

  • MZPtv Community Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 223
  • Gender: Male
    • AvP Galaxy
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #7 on: February 05, 2012, 01:40:32 PM »
2x01 -

(click to show/hide)
[/url]
Stargate Destiny - Coming Again Soon

Offline Pete D. Gaskell

  • Owner of a Dirty Mind and a Silver Tongue
  • Moderators
  • *
  • Posts: 3729
  • Gender: Male
  • You've got sarcasm. I've got a big gun.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Walker, Kings Cross, Cult Hero
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #8 on: February 19, 2012, 10:47:08 PM »
Okay then!

The S2 premiere of Premonition - I wasn't expecting this to arrive as quickly as it has, and I have to say I'm glad it did, as the episode picks up the baton and runs with it.

In fact, this season opener is one of the strongest episodes the series has done - Tony's writing has matured to an extremely confident level, and his full vision of the future that he's constructed for Premonition is given a complete showing here.

There are some eye-popping images scattered throughout, from the desolate Earth to the sprawling Alpha Prime - and they all add up to paint a vivid picture - superb VS writing.

But it's in the characterisation in which this episode succeeds so admirably - each of the main cast are re-introduced into the fray with at least one scene of their own - in arguably better fashion than in the pilot. Pairing Bow & Qulana is always a worthwhile move - the down-to-earth and the mysterious - and they get some great moments together stranded in the past. It's the crew of the Premonition, though, that get the best deal - Kanotris, Ducane and Rhade all shine, but it's Ilane who really impressed - given much more to do here than in the entirety of the first season!

Surprisingly, it's Morgan who comes off the worst, characterisation-wise, as his expanded role unfortunately confines him to a John McClane-esque action hero - complete with one-liners and an annoying habit of talking to himself! Despite that, his rescue scene was played well.

I'm also unsure about the new character of Twelve - he plays like a cross between Gary Seven and Doctor Who's The Doctor - but he comes across a little wishy-washy for my liking. It would perhaps have been more interesting to have seen Seven return instead, but I'm withholding full judgement until I see more of him...

The ending is also played exceptionally well - with challenges in two time periods, most notably the encounter between Bow and Premonition's crew as they prepare to steal the ship in the first place! Timey-wimey hijinks will ensue, I'm sure...

In short, a cracking season opener, showcasing what Premonition can do that no other Trek show can!

Offline Tony O'Stark

  • Movie/Mini-Series President
  • MZPtv Administrator
  • *
  • Posts: 23731
  • Gender: Male
  • Kicks ass. Takes names. Eats chicken.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Eternity, The Company
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #9 on: February 29, 2012, 09:42:02 PM »
2x01 -

Mollaro...is that a slight nod to Mollari from Babylon 5? What with the Centaurian planet as well?

On the nose nods, never mind slight! :D I love me my winks and in jokery.

Quote
:P Damn, that was mean! You canne leave it hanging like that! I’m always saying “take your time” when it comes to these things but I demand you finish this off ASAP! Really really enjoyed this episode. It’s nice to finally get some of the real backstory and and get a bit more depth to the Promonition’s situation.

Not quite sure who was the big player here but it definitely felt more like a strong story episode which I think you really needed. Very eager to keep going.

Thanks Aaron - and I hugely appreciate you reading.  thup

CREATOR/SHOWRUNNER:

The Beacon / Kings Cross

PRODUCER:

Walker

BLACK HOLE PRODUCTIONS / THE BLACK HOLE


Offline Tony O'Stark

  • Movie/Mini-Series President
  • MZPtv Administrator
  • *
  • Posts: 23731
  • Gender: Male
  • Kicks ass. Takes names. Eats chicken.
  • Favourite Virtual Series: Eternity, The Company
Re: [REVIEWS] 2x01 - "The End of Eden" (1)
« Reply #10 on: February 29, 2012, 09:45:57 PM »
Pete!

In fact, this season opener is one of the strongest episodes the series has done - Tony's writing has matured to an extremely confident level, and his full vision of the future that he's constructed for Premonition is given a complete showing here.

There are some eye-popping images scattered throughout, from the desolate Earth to the sprawling Alpha Prime - and they all add up to paint a vivid picture - superb VS writing.

*doffs hat* Too kind sir.

Quote
But it's in the characterisation in which this episode succeeds so admirably - each of the main cast are re-introduced into the fray with at least one scene of their own - in arguably better fashion than in the pilot. Pairing Bow & Qulana is always a worthwhile move - the down-to-earth and the mysterious - and they get some great moments together stranded in the past. It's the crew of the Premonition, though, that get the best deal - Kanotris, Ducane and Rhade all shine, but it's Ilane who really impressed - given much more to do here than in the entirety of the first season!

I was surprised at how easy it was to service pretty much everyone here, and it pleased me greatly.

Quote
Surprisingly, it's Morgan who comes off the worst, characterisation-wise, as his expanded role unfortunately confines him to a John McClane-esque action hero - complete with one-liners and an annoying habit of talking to himself! Despite that, his rescue scene was played well.

He's kind of meant to be a bit cheesy though, is Morgan - but I agree, his scenes here don't fly quite as I hoped.

Quote
I'm also unsure about the new character of Twelve - he plays like a cross between Gary Seven and Doctor Who's The Doctor - but he comes across a little wishy-washy for my liking. It would perhaps have been more interesting to have seen Seven return instead, but I'm withholding full judgement until I see more of him...

Early days here. You will get a better picture of Twelve a little down the road and see he's got a few more shades to him yet. But The Doctor is absolutely an inspiration, I confess.

Quote
In short, a cracking season opener, showcasing what Premonition can do that no other Trek show can!

Cheers dude! I'm pretty happy with it.

CREATOR/SHOWRUNNER:

The Beacon / Kings Cross

PRODUCER:

Walker

BLACK HOLE PRODUCTIONS / THE BLACK HOLE